An online product page shows a crossed-out price and the price you would actually pay. The crossed-out number is usually called the list price or the manufacturer’s suggested retail price, and it is the maker’s suggestion rather than what the market charges. It does a job that has very little to do with what the item costs anywhere else: it makes the second number look like a bargain.
This is how reference pricing works, and the guidance that governs it was written decades ago. What has changed is that Amazon now publishes some of the mechanics, price histories are easy to look up, and several of the tools that used to help shoppers check a deal have died or changed hands.
This guide explains list price vs. MSRP in plain English, why the crossed-out number is often theater, and how to test a discount with three numbers. The two-minute discount check is below.
In this article
| Label on the page | What it usually is | Who sets it |
|---|---|---|
| List price | A reference price, often the same figure as the MSRP | The maker, supplier or seller |
| MSRP | Manufacturer’s suggested retail price: a suggestion, not a shelf price | The manufacturer |
| Typical price | On Amazon, the 90-day median price customers actually paid | Calculated from sales |
| Was price | A former price, which may or may not be a real one | The retailer |
| Sale price | The number you would pay today | The retailer |
List price vs. MSRP: what each label means
Start with the word “suggested.” An MSRP is a number the manufacturer recommends, not a price anybody has to charge. A list price is the same idea wearing a different hat, and Amazon’s own help page says so directly: the List Price is “also known as the Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price, or MSRP,” and it is “the suggested retail price of a new product as provided by a manufacturer, supplier, or seller.”
So far, so harmless. The trouble starts when a retailer subtracts the suggestion from its own price and presents the difference as money you saved. The Federal Trade Commission has been writing about this since the 1960s, and its Guides Against Deceptive Pricing still sit in the Code of Federal Regulations as 16 CFR Part 233.
The regulator’s definition
Section 233.3(a) of those guides explains the mechanism in one paragraph. “Many members of the purchasing public believe that a manufacturer’s list price, or suggested retail price, is the price at which an article is generally sold,” it says. “Therefore, if a reduction from this price is advertised, many people will believe that they are being offered a genuine bargain.”
That belief is the whole trick. A number gets printed, shoppers read it as the normal price, and the discount is measured against a figure that may never have been normal at all.
Why a maker can print a number nobody pays
The agency does not pretend every MSRP is fake. Section 233.3(d) says a list price is legitimate when substantial sales actually happen at it in the advertiser’s trade area, usually in the stores that do not run on discounts. The guides call that a fair basis for comparison. The same section warns that a list price well above the highest price at which substantial sales occur in the advertiser’s trade area carries a clear and serious danger that shoppers are misled.
Then comes the sentence that explains a decade of online retail. “Today, only in the rare case are all sales of an article at the manufacturer’s suggested retail or list price,” section 233.3(c) says. Wide discounting has “seriously undermined the dependability of list prices as indicators of the exact prices at which articles are in fact generally sold at retail.”

Why the strikethrough is often theater
Two examples make the pattern easy to see. The first is a camera I checked myself in 2017, when the label and the market price disagreed in public.
The 2017 camera check
I ran the test on a GoPro HERO5 Black. Amazon showed a $399.99 list price and a $349.00 selling price. GoPro’s own site showed $399.99 minus a $50 discount, which comes to $349.99, a dollar above Amazon. Google Shopping showed about the same figure across sellers, with lower prices only for used or refurbished units.
I could not find a lower price for a new GoPro HERO5 Black anywhere I looked. The real price was about $349, and the $399.99 label dressed up what everyone was charging as a $50.99 saving. That observation is from 2017, but the mechanism has not changed.
One skillet, four list prices
The second example is public record. In March 2016, the New York Times reported on a Le Creuset iron-handle skillet, 11 3/4 inches wide, in cherry. Amazon said it would knock $60 off the $260 list price and sell the pan for $200.
The Times checked the same pan elsewhere. Williams-Sonoma listed a suggested price of $285 and sold it for $200. AllModern listed $250 and sold it for $200. Another retailer listed $285. The sale price barely moved, while the number that gets crossed out wandered from $250 to $285.
Set the arithmetic straight and the discount shrinks to something ordinary. A $260 label against a $200 price is $60 off, or 23.1% off the label. But if every serious retailer sells the pan for $200, the honest comparison is $200 against $200, which is no discount at all. The Times put the conclusion bluntly: with many products online, you could not pay the list price even if you wanted to, because hardly anyone was charging it.
Both examples follow the same script. A label gets printed, the market settles somewhere below it, and the gap between the two becomes a permanent sale.
What makes a “was” price honest
Section 233.1 sets out what makes a “was” price honest, and the list is stricter than a sale banner suggests. The former price must be the actual, bona fide price at which the item was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time. It must have been offered openly and actively, in the recent, regular course of business, honestly and in good faith. And it cannot be an artificial, inflated figure created so that a later cut looks dramatic.
The commission’s own small example is worth keeping in mind. An advertiser who claims an item has been “Reduced to $9.99” when the former price was $10 is misleading the shopper, because a 1 cent difference is not the bargain the word suggests. A label can be technically accurate and still tell a story that is not true.
A local newsroom took up the same question in a consumer segment titled “Dollars & Sense: Fake sales – The discount deception.” The segment makes the trick easier to spot the next time a page shows you two prices.

How reference prices work now
Distrusting the label and checking the market still works. Two developments make it easier. Amazon publishes some of the rules it uses before it prints a strikethrough, and price histories for a single product are now simple to look up. That makes the help page a useful case study rather than an accusation.
The 90-day and 180-day windows
According to Amazon’s help page on strike-through pricing, the company will only display a List Price if the product was purchased by customers on Amazon, or offered by other retailers, at or above that List Price within the past 90 days for non-seasonal products. Seasonal goods such as ski jackets and shoes get 180 days. Books are the stated exception. The same page concedes that list prices “may not necessarily reflect the prevailing market price of a product.”
Read that closely and it describes a floor, not a promise. A label can survive the test because one seller somewhere offered that price during the window Amazon checks. It does not prove that shoppers were lining up to pay it.
The typical price is a median
Amazon’s other reference price is more useful to a shopper. The Typical Price is “the 90-day median price paid by customers for the product on Amazon,” and the company says it excludes prices paid during limited-time promotions, along with purchases in Amazon Haul and Amazon Now. Certain grocery items use regional prices, and Amazon Fresh uses a 35-day median of prices offered locally.
For most items, a median of what Amazon customers actually paid is a very different animal from a manufacturer’s suggestion. It is also a fairer benchmark than the label, because the standard 90-day Typical Price is built from completed sales rather than intentions.
What the rules do not cover
None of this settles what any particular retailer is allowed to do. The FTC guides describe a national standard for deceptive pricing, states have their own consumer protection laws, and a single product page can raise questions that only a regulator or a court can answer. The useful takeaway for a shopper is narrower: there is a standard, it is written down, and it gives you specific questions to ask of a label.

The two-minute discount check
Three numbers answer the question for a single item. Write down the list price, the asking price, and the best price you can find for the same item at another retailer. If you can find a 90-day low, add that too. Then run the arithmetic, or let the checker below do it.
Discount reality check
Enter the label price and the price you would actually pay. It shows what each number is really saying. Tap or click to open.
Enter a list price and an asking price to see what the label is doing.
This only compares the numbers you type. It cannot see a price you did not look up.
What the three numbers tell you
The label arithmetic answers one question: how far below the printed reference is this price? That is the number in the advertisement, and it is the least useful of the three. The market comparison answers a better question: is this cheaper than the same item somewhere else? The 90-day low answers the best question of all: is this actually a good price for this product, or just the usual price with a new banner?
When the asking price matches the best price elsewhere, the label is describing the market rather than a saving. When it sits above the best price elsewhere, the label is measuring a saving against a price other sellers have already abandoned. When it falls below both, you have found something the label alone could not tell you.
When a real discount exists
Real discounts exist, and the rules describe how to recognize one. Section 233.1(b) says a former price is not necessarily fictitious just because no sales happened at it, provided the price was openly and actively offered for a reasonable period, in the recent and regular course of business, in good faith. Section 233.3(d) uses the same test for a list price: substantial sales at that level in the advertiser’s trade area make it a fair comparison.
In practice that means a genuine sale tends to have a boring explanation. A store held a price for months, then cut it. A seasonal item is moving into clearance. A maker is discontinuing a color. The discount has a reason you can state without pointing at the crossed-out number.
What to do with a price that fails the check
The check that matters compares the same model across two or three retailers, then looks at the price history for that exact product rather than the category. Price history is where the label meets what people actually paid, and a line chart cannot be marked down.
Google Shopping still works as a first stop for a cross-retailer comparison: google.com/shopping lists sellers and prices for the same item. Keepa, a site that bills itself as an Amazon price tracker, is built for that job. Capital One Shopping, a free browser extension and app, searches retailers for better prices, tests coupon codes and can notify you when a price drops, according to Capital One’s own description of the tool.
The same test travels well. A guide to negotiating appliance prices at the store applies it in person. A comparison of ALDI and Walmart baskets applies it to groceries. The AliExpress buying guide applies it to marketplace listings, where the reference price is even further from a shelf.
CamelCamelCamel, a name that still circulates for this job, answers automated checks with a bot challenge, so its current state is unverified here. Use it only after your own check that it does what you expect.
The tools that changed shape
Not every tool survives. Three services that shopping advice recommended in the late 2010s no longer do that job, even though their web addresses still answer. Blinq, once a marketplace for open-box and used goods, now redirects to blinq.me, a digital business-card company. Paribus redirects to Capital One Shopping. Earny’s domain is now a GoDaddy for-sale page.
That is the quiet failure mode of any old shopping guide. A link check returns a green light because something is still there, while the service behind the link has changed shape or disappeared. The live tools above are the ones to use. The dead ones stay named here so nobody follows an old link to a service that no longer does the job.
Frequently asked questions
Is MSRP the same as list price?
In practice, yes. MSRP stands for manufacturer’s suggested retail price, and Amazon’s help page describes its List Price as “also known as the Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price, or MSRP.” Both are reference prices set by a maker or seller, not prices that a store has to charge.
Why do stores show a strikethrough price?
Because a reference price changes how a second number feels. The Federal Trade Commission’s pricing guides note that shoppers read a manufacturer’s list price as the price at which an item is generally sold, so a reduction from it looks like a genuine bargain. The strikethrough supplies the comparison, whether or not the comparison reflects the market.
Are fake original prices against the rules?
The FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing treat a fictitious former price as deceptive, and they define one as an artificial, inflated price set up to make a later cut look large. State consumer protection laws can add their own rules.
Does a “was” price mean the item is on sale?
No. A “was” price is a seller’s own figure, and section 233.1 of the guides requires a former price to be real, recent and offered in good faith before it can support a bargain claim. Without a market comparison or a price history, the label cannot tell you whether anything changed except the banner.
How can I tell whether a discount is real?
Compare three numbers: the list price, the asking price and the best price you can find for the same item elsewhere. If the asking price matches the best price elsewhere, the label is describing the market. If it beats that price, you have a genuine saving. A 90-day price history makes the answer clearer still.
Sources
All sources below were read in November 2026. The percentages here are simple arithmetic on the figures quoted.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR Part 233, Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, sections 233.1 and 233.3.
- Amazon Customer Service. Strike-Through Pricing and Savings.
- The New York Times. David Streitfeld, It’s Discounted, but Is It a Deal? How List Prices Lost Their Meaning, 6 March 2016.
- Capital One. Capital One Shopping: A free tool to find deals online, 12 March 2026.
- Keepa. Amazon price tracker, checked 7 November 2026.
This article is for general information and entertainment, not financial advice.
Updated November 2026 by Richie with the help of modern digital tools.
Leave a Reply