The Rich Miser

Google Maps vs. Waze – Avoiding Sketchy Neighborhoods

I don’t know if it’s happened to you, but it’s happened to me. I get in the car during rush hour and put my destination into a GPS navigation app. I get going, confident that the app is routing me the most efficient way possible, around the major traffic jams. 20 minutes later, I see why I’m moving so fast: there’s little traffic, but it’s because I’m right in the middle of a sketchy, high-crime neighborhood. My glee turns into fear, as I count down the second ’till I get out of there.

Bars on windows? Not a good sign…

After this happened to me a few times, I did some research, and am now much better at avoiding high-crime areas. Here’s a rundown of how to do that, on my two favorite navigation apps: Waze and Google Maps.

Waze: Get There Fast, At All Costs

The Miracle of Waze

Waze is my favorite navigation app, and an amazing piece of technology. What’s great about it is that it not only takes general traffic data into account (like the one you hear on the radio, telling you where the major jams and accidents are), but also the speed and location of every one of its users (called “Wazers”), to make a real-time map of your area and its road conditions. Also, Wazers can report jams, red-light cameras, hazards, police officers, and other road issues, which Waze takes into account and integrates into its maps.

So, for example, if suddenly seven cars on one avenue start moving very slowly, and they’re all using Waze, the app will know that there’s a jam or other slowdown on that route, and will navigate people away from it.

Waze map showing traffic jams, road closures, and a red-light camera.

Waze user report.

A One-Track Mind

On its default settings, Waze has one goal: to get you to your destination in the shortest amount of time, using any legal route. And therein lies the sketchy-neighborhood problem.

When the highways are backed up, Waze will send you down the fastest legal route, period. Even if it means driving through quiet residential neighborhoods, and even if it means driving right down the middle of the highest-crime, sketchiest areas in the city. It’s not about your physical safety, it’s about getting you there quickly.

All of this means that you can get lucky, and save time by driving through here:

But you can also get unlucky, and be sent through these places:

Google Maps: The Prudent Alternative

Google Maps is kind of like Waze’s more prudent, reasonable cousin. While it has traffic data, it does not seem to be as up-to-the-minute as Waze. It also lacks things like red-light cameras and police on its maps.

Color-coded traffic data on Google Maps.

Waze is generally better at getting you somewhere faster. However, Google Maps, unlike Waze, will usually avoid high-crime and rough neighborhoods, simply because it tends to stay on major highways and avenues. In other words, Google Maps will, in my experience, route you through whichever highway or major road is fastest, but it will not send you through quiet suburbs or run-down city blocks.

So, while I can’t guarantee that Google Maps will avoid dilapidated neighborhoods or sketchy boulevards, I can say that it will generally route you through them far less than Waze, even if it means you get to your destination a little later.

Putting It All Together

Knowing all this, we can distill a few rules of the road:

1. If it’s not rush hour, it’s generally safe to use Waze.

2. If you know the city and know where the run-down areas are, you can still use Waze and simply choose the better route, like so:

After putting in your destination, tap “Routes”.

Compare and choose between routes.

3. If you don’t know the city, just use Google Maps.

Happy travels!

*Disclaimer: The pictures are stock photos. They’re not meant to represent any particular place.

Live it up, spend less.
Get notified of new posts by e-mail.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *